Cloth Napkins
Cloth napkins may seem unnecessarily fancy when paper towels exist, but they are worth the investment. They add an air of stability and permanence to the dinner table, like you have settled in to live here. Their thickness and absorbency is superior to paper, so you don't have to go through a bunch of them to mop up one minor spill. And their reusability means they produce less waste and are cheaper over time.
Of course, cloth napkins also mean more laundry. They require commitment. There's more overhead than just tossing it in the trash when you're done. And the cost of a nice set of napkins (like everything else these days) can be off-puttingly high.
After much deliberation, I chose Quince's organic cotton napkins in terracotta. A 12-pack cost me $39.90 plus shipping. Unfortunately, they just recently stopped carrying these! Here are some alternatives:

These are linen instead of cotton, but have the same rust color that I love.

Quince still offers organic cotton terracotta napkins, just with a different texture.

I absolutely love gingham, and this one is still neutral enough to fit in many different homes.